On Thu, 16 Feb 2012, Riccardo (Jack) Lucchetti wrote:
On Thu, 16 Feb 2012, Helgi Tomasson wrote:
> I am doing a panel-data exercise from Greene (5th. ed. ) exercise 13.1
> Why do I get precisely the same estimates in pooled OLS as in the
> random-effects panel model?
Here's the answer to your question
> 'Within' variance = 3.0455
> 'Between' variance = 0.113088
> theta used for quasi-demeaning = 0
In finite samples, it may well happen that the estimate for theta goes
outside its 'natural' limits (the 0-1 interval), in which case it's force d
to 0. See any textbook for details (eg Greene --- used to be section 13.4 in
the 5th edition, don't known in more recent versions).
Footnote: stata's "xtreg" command produces the same result as
gretl on the data Helgi posted, for the random effects model.
Allin Cottrell