On Fri, 22 Jul 2011, amaryl wrote:
I'm running a qlrtest for a structural break in a simpel
OLS-regression
with a constant and two dependend variables. gretl gives me a
break-date, significant at the one-percent-level, the critical value of
which is given as 6.02. gretl gives as source of those critical values
Stock and Watson (2003): Introduction in Econometrics.
I take it, those asymptotic critical values for a qlr test were
originally calculated by Andrews (1993) and corrected also by Andrews
(2003). I just checked with the Andrews (2003) paper and if I read that
table correctly, the critical value of a qlr test with 15% trimming and
3 degrees of freedom is 18.07.
Yes, Andrews is the source for the values given in Stock and
Watson. But the values are consistent. Andrews gives critical
values for chi-square(q) whereas the S&W approach, used in
gretl, is to compute an F-test. The critical values for the
latter are the values given by Andrews divided by q.
Allin Cottrell