Re: [Gretl-devel] [Gretl-users] smpl in a function

Hi Peter, Thanks for following this up. Here's the deal: First, you got a misleading error message, "Bad character 'b' in date string". That is fixed in my source tree and wll be fixed in CVS as soon as sourceforge CVS is up again (unfortunately it's broken right now). However, the other part of the error message, namely error in new starting obs was quite correct: your function tried to push the start of the sample range outside of the range passed in by the caller, which is not allowed. This is because of the way that firstobs() and lastobs() work at present -- as noted in the Function Reference. That is, firstobs() gives the observation number for the first non-missing value of its series argument, but this may occur before the start of the current sample range. There's a case for changing that, so that firstobs() and lastobs() do not return values outside of the current sample, but that would be backward incompatible so I'm not going to make the change uniterally; I'll raise the question on the devel list. I'm attaching a modified (skeletal) version of your script that shows how to deal with sampling inside a function. If we decide to change firstobs() and lastobs() this will still work, although the conditional stuff with the '?' operator would become redundant. Allin